Robert Rutley, Broker Associate,
Mott & Chace Sotheby’s International Realty
____
Rhode Island’s housing market continues to challenge buyers in 2025, with high demand, limited inventory, and rising prices—especially in the Providence-Warwick metro area. According to the National Association of REALTORS® (NAR), the region experienced a 3.3% home price appreciation over the past three years, reflecting sustained upward pressure on affordability. National Association of REALTORS®+1National Association of REALTORS®+1
For buyers, especially first-timers, this environment can be daunting. But understanding the key pitfalls—and how to navigate them—can make the difference between frustration and success.
Common Pitfalls for Buyers in a Seller’s Market
1. Underestimating Competition
In Rhode Island, homes often receive multiple offers shortly after listing. Buyers who delay or submit low offers risk losing out. In Pawtuxet, for example, median listing prices jumped from $512,000 in 2021 to $684,500 by mid-2024, with many homes selling well over asking. Business Insider
2. Skipping Due Diligence
Waiving inspections or contingencies to appear more competitive can bring your offer to the top of the pile, but can also have consequences. Speak with your agent about those consequences, your options, and how to handle hidden issues may surface post-purchase. Buying a Home Warranty may give you peace of mind.
3. Emotional Bidding
The fear of missing out can drive buyers to bid beyond their means, or get caught up in bidding on a home that doesn’t fit their needs. This can lead to potential regrets once the dust settles. Personally, I’m a fan of making good decisions. I’ll always present you with facts to counter or support your decisions.
4. Waiting for Rates to Drop
While mortgage rates have declined from 7.04% to 6.51% in late 2024, waiting for further decreases might be counterproductive. NAR Chief Economist Lawrence Yun notes that pent-up demand could surge if rates fall, intensifying competition. National Association of REALTORS®+1National Association of REALTORS®+1Business Insider
Smart Strategies for Rhode Island Buyers
1. Get Pre-Approved and Set a Firm Budget
Pre-approval strengthens your offer and clarifies your financial boundaries. Also, be aware that the amount that you’re approved for may be higher than your usual living budget. It’s not worth it to be house poor - let’s take those vacations. Find you sweet spot and stick to it to avoid overextending yourself. Realtor+5Investopedia+5National Association of REALTORS®+5
2. Work with a Local REALTOR®
This is simply calling out the obvious. Going into battle without the tools to survive and win will never get you a home. An experienced buyer’s agent can provide insights into neighborhood trends, guide you through bidding strategies, and help identify properties before they hit the market.
3. Consider Fixer-Uppers
Some buyers are finding success by targeting homes that need work. This is an opportunity to create the home of your dreams, if you have the umph to go through a gut renovation project. In Pawtuxet Village, a couple secured a fixer-upper in a desirable area after being outbid on multiple move-in-ready homes. Business Insider
4. Be Ready to Act Quickly
In a fast-moving market, hesitation can mean missing out. Have your financing, down payment, and decision-making process ready to go. Work with a lender and an agent that also responds quickly and moves as fast as( or faster ) than you do.
Here’s a tip: Text or email your agent/lender team on a Sunday afternoon. Do you get a response shortly or are you wanting until the beginning of the workweek, after 9am on Monday?
5. Understand the Process of Waiving Essential Contingencies
While it's tempting to waive inspections or financing contingencies, only do so when you fully understand the win’s and repercussions of these serious decisions.
Final Thoughts
Rhode Island’s seller’s market presents challenges, but informed and prepared buyers can still find opportunities. By understanding the market dynamics and employing strategic approaches, you can navigate the competitive landscape and secure a home that meets your needs.
If you need further or specific information on how to best get your offer seen and accepted in an intense Rhode Island seller’s market, please reach out to me. I’m happy to discuss a strategy that works best for you, balancing your risk vs reward values.
